Sicilian: Alapin, 2...e6 3.d4 d5 5.Nf3
Sicilian: Alapin, 2...e6 3.d4 d5 4.exd5 exd5 5.Nf3
Definition
The line arises from the Sicilian Defence after the moves 1. e4 c5 2. c3 e6 3. d4 d5 4. exd5 exd5 5. Nf3. It is a branch of the Alapin Variation in which Black answers 2.c3 with a French-style pawn structure (…e6 and …d5) rather than the more common 2…d5 or 2…Nf6. The early central exchanges leave an open centre with symmetrical pawns on d5 and e4 removed, leading to positions that often resemble the French Exchange or certain Queen’s Gambit structures rather than a typical Sicilian.
Move Order & Key Position
- 1. e4 c5
- 2. c3 e6 (Black prepares …d5 before White can establish a strong pawn centre.)
- 3. d4 d5 (The immediate counter in the centre.)
- 4. exd5 exd5 (Symmetrical exchange; both sides now have an isolated pawn square on d4/d5.)
- 5. Nf3 (Developing and eyeing e5.)
The resulting tabiya after 5.Nf3 is:
Strategic Themes
- Open, symmetrical centre: With the e- and d-pawns exchanged, piece activity becomes paramount. Neither side holds a classical Sicilian pawn majority on the queenside.
- Minor-piece placement:
- White often develops Bf1–b5 or Bc4, pressuring d5 and targeting Black’s queenside.
- Black’s light-squared bishop may reach d6 or e7; on d6 it exerts pressure on h2 and reinforces d5.
- Isolated or hanging pawns: After the thematic 6…Nf6 7.Bb5+ Bd7 8.O-O, exchanges can yield an isolated d5 pawn for Black or hanging pawns on c5/d5 depending on pawn breaks.
- e- and c-file play: Both rooks frequently occupy half-open files (Re1, Rc1 / Re8, Rc8), leading to tactical opportunities against loose minor pieces.
- Transpositional potential: The structure can transpose into the Exchange French (1.e4 e6 2.d4 d5 3.exd5 exd5) but with an extra …c5 for Black, granting counter-play on the c-file.
Typical Plans for Each Side
- White
- Rapid development with Bf1-b5, O-O, Re1 to control the centre and prepare c4 or dxc5.
- Pressure the d5 pawn by doubling on the d-file (Qd3, Rad1).
- Queenside expansion with b4–b5 if Black castles short and delays …c4.
- Black
- Counterplay via …Nf6, …Nc6 and possibly …Bg4, targeting d4 and pinning Nf3.
- Pawn breaks …cxd4 followed by …Qb6 to challenge White’s centre.
- If White plays Bb5+, calmly respond …Bd7 and aim for minority attack on the queenside with …b6, …a6 and rooks to the c-file.
Historical Context
The Alapin (named after Russian master Semyon Alapin, 1856-1923) was introduced as an anti-Sicilian system, striving to sidestep the labyrinth of Open Sicilian theory. The 2…e6 line became fashionable in the late 1980s when French-defense specialists realised they could import familiar structures into the Sicilian. Grandmasters such as Michael Adams, Sergey Tiviakov, and Vladimir Kramnik have employed 2…e6 3.d4 d5 with success, lending the variation theoretical credibility.
Illustrative Games
-
M. Adams – V. Kramnik, Dos Hermanas 1997
Showing Black’s dynamic pawn sacrifice …cxd4 …Bb4+ leading to active piece play and an eventual endgame advantage.
-
Fabiano Caruana – Maxime Vachier-Lagrave, Paris Rapid 2019
Demonstrates modern treatment: White expands with b4-b5, but MVL’s counterpunch …Bg4 and central break …d4 seized the initiative.
-
Alexander Morozevich – Michael Adams, Wijk aan Zee 2002
Classic example of Black adopting a French-Exchange set-up, equalising comfortably and later outplaying White in a knight endgame.
Interesting Facts & Anecdotes
- In the 1998 Linares press room, Kramnik famously joked, “Why take on the Najdorf when you can make them play a French without even knowing it?”—referring to this very line.
- The variation is popular in correspondence and engine chess because the symmetrical pawn structure leaves plenty of scope for deep strategic manoeuvring rather than forcing tactical main lines.
- Despite starting from the Sicilian Defence, Black castles kingside first only about 55 % of the time in master games, reflecting the flexibility of the resulting positions.
Current Theoretical Verdict
Computer engines rate the position after 5.Nf3 as approximately equal (≈ 0.10–0.20 pawns for White) but extremely playable for both sides. At elite level it is used as a low-risk surprise weapon: White steers the game away from heavily analysed Sicilian labyrinths, while Black enjoys an unbalanced yet sound structure with clear plans.